Honorable Mentions Not everything we test makes the cut as a pick, but that doesn’t mean it’s a bad mattress topper. Here are a few that our testers slept on and got a good night’s sleep with but didn’t love as much as the picks above. Avocado Alpaca Topper for $1,240: If you’re looking for
The cotton and wool layers are GOTS-certified organic, while the Dunlop latex carries the GOLS certification. The finished product does not have any certifications beyond Greenguard Gold, but the material is undyed, which is great for anyone bothered by industrial dyes. As with most of these organic options, the Coyuchi is made without chemicals, foam,
The upgraded membership ($25 per month, $299 annually) extends the warranty to five years, which is important with such an investment. Although I haven’t experienced any hardware issues yet, the system relies on pumps, tubes, and sensors that run every night. This introduces more points of failure than traditional mattresses, and consumers have reported warranty
